Electric Automation Forum
Forum » General Discussion » can an protection relay system of a switchgear panel be replaced by relay of different make?
Topics: can an protection relay system of a switchgear panel be replaced by relay of different make? on General Discussion
#1
Start by
Ashish Kumar
08-25-2014 11:32 PM

can an protection relay system of a switchgear panel be replaced by relay of different make?

Can an protection relay system of a switchgear panel be replaced by relay of different make?
08-26-2014 02:12 AM
Top #2
Paul Best
08-26-2014 02:12 AM
It is always good practice to replace like for like componants..but if you are finding problems sourcing. May a suggest a company that deal with obsolete and hard to find items? Look up Mark5, this company are based in the UK but I believe they can ship out to other countries if required..
Regards
08-26-2014 04:21 AM
Top #3
Vilas Vaidya
08-26-2014 04:21 AM
it is possible if you get equivalant relays
changing is recommended only if required
vdvaidya
elctrical consulntant mumbai
08-26-2014 07:11 AM
Top #4
Raghunath Rompicherla
08-26-2014 07:11 AM
I don't see a problem functionally. You have to deal with issues like
* relay dimensions / cut-out changes on the panel
* Wiring changes
* Drawing / scheme changes
* Relay setting / programming / configuring etc.
These are extra works, but manageable
08-26-2014 09:52 AM
Top #5
Vaishali Kharva
08-26-2014 09:52 AM
Yes we can use different make relay for protection relay system of a switchgear panel.

The rating and functions have to be same.
08-26-2014 12:28 PM
Top #6
Bharathram Pattabiraman
08-26-2014 12:28 PM
Theoretically speaking, yes. But, you would have to go into the details to match the inputs and the outputs of the two relays.
08-26-2014 02:35 PM
Top #7
Stuart Hutchinson
08-26-2014 02:35 PM
Yes. I've had no choice but to do this previously on old equipment with obsolete relays. Its always preferable for the OEM to carry out the engineering/installation but this isn't always possible for old equipment as companies go out of business, etc. If OEM isn't available then a specialist company with detailed knowledge of the equipment is usually able to take on the work.
08-26-2014 05:12 PM
Top #8
Daniel Mougin
08-26-2014 05:12 PM
Except if the existing relay is a self powered relay with "propriatairy" specific CTs, it should be possible to replace the relay.
Take also care if the application, differential for example,of the new relay requires particular specifications for the CTs
Reply to Thread